Marketing Attribution Models: Choosing the Best for Your Business

Home

Main Blog Page

Marketing Attribution Models: How to Choose the Right One for Your Business

Marketing Attribution Models...

Marketing Attribution Models: How to Choose the Right One for Your Business

Main Blog Page

•

5 min read

How Automation is Revolutionizing ACH Process…

5 min read

Marketing attribution models help companies understand which of their marketing efforts are most effective in driving conversions. For Chief Marketing Officers (CMOs), choosing the right attribution model is key to optimizing campaigns and improving ROI. Whether you’re considering first-click, last-click, or multi-touch models, each approach has its strengths and weaknesses. Selecting the most appropriate model depends on your specific marketing goals, sales cycle, and available resources.

In this guide, we will explore the pros and cons of common attribution models and how to choose the right one for accurate performance measurement.

The Pros and Cons of Different Attribution Models

First-Click Attribution

Last-Click Attribution

Linear Attribution

Time Decay Attribution

Position-Based (U-Shaped) Attribution

Custom or Algorithmic Attribution

First-Click Attribution

Last-Click Attribution

Linear Attribution

Time Decay Attribution

Position-Based (U-Shaped) Attribution

Custom or Algorithmic Attribution

Each attribution model allocates credit for conversions differently, and the choice of model can significantly affect how you interpret the success of your marketing channels.

First-Click Attribution
First-click attribution gives 100% of the conversion credit to the first interaction a customer has with your brand, no matter how many touchpoints occur afterward.
- Pros:
  - Highlights the channel that initiates the customer journey.
  - Useful for understanding which touchpoints are effective at building awareness.
- Cons:
  - Ignores the influence of later touchpoints that may have driven the final decision.
  - May undervalue middle- and bottom-funnel activities like retargeting or nurture emails.
- Best for: Brands focused on top-of-funnel activities such as driving brand awareness and acquiring new leads.
Last-Click Attribution
In last-click attribution, all credit for the conversion is given to the final touchpoint that leads directly to the purchase or desired action.
- Pros:
  - Simple to implement and commonly used in many analytics platforms.
  - Shows the touchpoint that directly influenced the final purchase decision.
- Cons:
  - Fails to account for earlier interactions that built trust and engagement.
  - Overemphasizes closing tactics while undervaluing brand-building efforts.
- Best for: Businesses with short sales cycles or those focused on optimizing conversion rate and direct response campaigns.
Linear Attribution
This model spreads credit equally across all touchpoints a customer interacts with during their journey, from the first touch to the final conversion.
- Pros:
  - Provides a holistic view of the entire customer journey.
  - Fairly distributes credit across all interactions, offering insights into how different channels contribute to conversions.
- Cons:
  - Treats all touchpoints as equally important, even if some had a greater impact than others.
  - Oversimplifies the relationship between touchpoints and conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with complex sales cycles that want to understand the full breadth of their marketing efforts.
Time Decay Attribution
This model gives more credit to touchpoints that occur closer to the final conversion, under the assumption that more recent interactions are more influential in driving the conversion.
- Pros:
  - Emphasizes the touchpoints that led the customer to make a final decision.
  - Useful for businesses that focus on nurturing leads through retargeting and follow-up campaigns.
- Cons:
  - May undervalue top-of-funnel activities that initially introduced the customer to the brand.
  - Assumes recency is the most important factor in driving conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with longer sales cycles or those that rely on lead nurturing and remarketing efforts to convert customers.
Position-Based (U-Shaped) Attribution
This model assigns 40% of the credit to the first touchpoint, 40% to the last touchpoint, and distributes the remaining 20% evenly across all middle interactions.
- Pros:
  - Recognizes the importance of both the initial awareness stage and the final conversion point.
  - Gives some credit to the middle touchpoints, helping to capture the full customer journey.
- Cons:
  - The distribution of credit may not accurately reflect the true influence of each interaction.
  - Still somewhat arbitrary in how it splits the middle interactions.
- Best for: Businesses that want to balance the importance of customer acquisition and closing efforts while also considering the role of mid-funnel activities.
Custom or Algorithmic Attribution
This model uses machine learning or custom algorithms to assign credit based on the actual impact each touchpoint has on conversion, analyzing historical data and customer behavior.
- Pros:
  - Highly accurate and tailored to the specific customer journey of your business.
  - Provides deep insights into how each marketing channel truly influences conversions.
- Cons:
  - Requires advanced data analytics tools and expertise to implement.
  - Resource-intensive and more complex to manage compared to standard models.
- Best for: Large businesses with extensive customer data and the resources to build a tailored attribution model.

Each attribution model allocates credit for conversions differently, and the choice of model can significantly affect how you interpret the success of your marketing channels.

First-Click Attribution
First-click attribution gives 100% of the conversion credit to the first interaction a customer has with your brand, no matter how many touchpoints occur afterward.
- Pros:
  - Highlights the channel that initiates the customer journey.
  - Useful for understanding which touchpoints are effective at building awareness.
- Cons:
  - Ignores the influence of later touchpoints that may have driven the final decision.
  - May undervalue middle- and bottom-funnel activities like retargeting or nurture emails.
- Best for: Brands focused on top-of-funnel activities such as driving brand awareness and acquiring new leads.
Last-Click Attribution
In last-click attribution, all credit for the conversion is given to the final touchpoint that leads directly to the purchase or desired action.
- Pros:
  - Simple to implement and commonly used in many analytics platforms.
  - Shows the touchpoint that directly influenced the final purchase decision.
- Cons:
  - Fails to account for earlier interactions that built trust and engagement.
  - Overemphasizes closing tactics while undervaluing brand-building efforts.
- Best for: Businesses with short sales cycles or those focused on optimizing conversion rate and direct response campaigns.
Linear Attribution
This model spreads credit equally across all touchpoints a customer interacts with during their journey, from the first touch to the final conversion.
- Pros:
  - Provides a holistic view of the entire customer journey.
  - Fairly distributes credit across all interactions, offering insights into how different channels contribute to conversions.
- Cons:
  - Treats all touchpoints as equally important, even if some had a greater impact than others.
  - Oversimplifies the relationship between touchpoints and conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with complex sales cycles that want to understand the full breadth of their marketing efforts.
Time Decay Attribution
This model gives more credit to touchpoints that occur closer to the final conversion, under the assumption that more recent interactions are more influential in driving the conversion.
- Pros:
  - Emphasizes the touchpoints that led the customer to make a final decision.
  - Useful for businesses that focus on nurturing leads through retargeting and follow-up campaigns.
- Cons:
  - May undervalue top-of-funnel activities that initially introduced the customer to the brand.
  - Assumes recency is the most important factor in driving conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with longer sales cycles or those that rely on lead nurturing and remarketing efforts to convert customers.
Position-Based (U-Shaped) Attribution
This model assigns 40% of the credit to the first touchpoint, 40% to the last touchpoint, and distributes the remaining 20% evenly across all middle interactions.
- Pros:
  - Recognizes the importance of both the initial awareness stage and the final conversion point.
  - Gives some credit to the middle touchpoints, helping to capture the full customer journey.
- Cons:
  - The distribution of credit may not accurately reflect the true influence of each interaction.
  - Still somewhat arbitrary in how it splits the middle interactions.
- Best for: Businesses that want to balance the importance of customer acquisition and closing efforts while also considering the role of mid-funnel activities.
Custom or Algorithmic Attribution
This model uses machine learning or custom algorithms to assign credit based on the actual impact each touchpoint has on conversion, analyzing historical data and customer behavior.
- Pros:
  - Highly accurate and tailored to the specific customer journey of your business.
  - Provides deep insights into how each marketing channel truly influences conversions.
- Cons:
  - Requires advanced data analytics tools and expertise to implement.
  - Resource-intensive and more complex to manage compared to standard models.
- Best for: Large businesses with extensive customer data and the resources to build a tailored attribution model.

Each attribution model allocates credit for conversions differently, and the choice of model can significantly affect how you interpret the success of your marketing channels.

First-Click Attribution
First-click attribution gives 100% of the conversion credit to the first interaction a customer has with your brand, no matter how many touchpoints occur afterward.
- Pros:
  - Highlights the channel that initiates the customer journey.
  - Useful for understanding which touchpoints are effective at building awareness.
- Cons:
  - Ignores the influence of later touchpoints that may have driven the final decision.
  - May undervalue middle- and bottom-funnel activities like retargeting or nurture emails.
- Best for: Brands focused on top-of-funnel activities such as driving brand awareness and acquiring new leads.
Last-Click Attribution
In last-click attribution, all credit for the conversion is given to the final touchpoint that leads directly to the purchase or desired action.
- Pros:
  - Simple to implement and commonly used in many analytics platforms.
  - Shows the touchpoint that directly influenced the final purchase decision.
- Cons:
  - Fails to account for earlier interactions that built trust and engagement.
  - Overemphasizes closing tactics while undervaluing brand-building efforts.
- Best for: Businesses with short sales cycles or those focused on optimizing conversion rate and direct response campaigns.
Linear Attribution
This model spreads credit equally across all touchpoints a customer interacts with during their journey, from the first touch to the final conversion.
- Pros:
  - Provides a holistic view of the entire customer journey.
  - Fairly distributes credit across all interactions, offering insights into how different channels contribute to conversions.
- Cons:
  - Treats all touchpoints as equally important, even if some had a greater impact than others.
  - Oversimplifies the relationship between touchpoints and conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with complex sales cycles that want to understand the full breadth of their marketing efforts.
Time Decay Attribution
This model gives more credit to touchpoints that occur closer to the final conversion, under the assumption that more recent interactions are more influential in driving the conversion.
- Pros:
  - Emphasizes the touchpoints that led the customer to make a final decision.
  - Useful for businesses that focus on nurturing leads through retargeting and follow-up campaigns.
- Cons:
  - May undervalue top-of-funnel activities that initially introduced the customer to the brand.
  - Assumes recency is the most important factor in driving conversions.
- Best for: Businesses with longer sales cycles or those that rely on lead nurturing and remarketing efforts to convert customers.
Position-Based (U-Shaped) Attribution
This model assigns 40% of the credit to the first touchpoint, 40% to the last touchpoint, and distributes the remaining 20% evenly across all middle interactions.
- Pros:
  - Recognizes the importance of both the initial awareness stage and the final conversion point.
  - Gives some credit to the middle touchpoints, helping to capture the full customer journey.
- Cons:
  - The distribution of credit may not accurately reflect the true influence of each interaction.
  - Still somewhat arbitrary in how it splits the middle interactions.
- Best for: Businesses that want to balance the importance of customer acquisition and closing efforts while also considering the role of mid-funnel activities.
Custom or Algorithmic Attribution
This model uses machine learning or custom algorithms to assign credit based on the actual impact each touchpoint has on conversion, analyzing historical data and customer behavior.
- Pros:
  - Highly accurate and tailored to the specific customer journey of your business.
  - Provides deep insights into how each marketing channel truly influences conversions.
- Cons:
  - Requires advanced data analytics tools and expertise to implement.
  - Resource-intensive and more complex to manage compared to standard models.
- Best for: Large businesses with extensive customer data and the resources to build a tailored attribution model.

How to Select the Right Model for Accurate Performance Measurement

Understand Your Customer Journey

Align with Your Marketing Goals
Consider the Length and Complexity of Your Sales Cycle

Evaluate Your Resources
Test and Refine Over Time

Understand Your Customer Journey

Align with Your Marketing Goals
Consider the Length and Complexity of Your Sales Cycle

Evaluate Your Resources
Test and Refine Over Time

Choosing the right attribution model depends on your business goals, marketing strategies, and the complexity of your customer journey. Here are some key factors to consider when selecting the best model for your business:

Understand Your Customer Journey
Mapping out your customer journey is the first step in selecting an attribution model. Identify the key touchpoints where customers interact with your brand. Are they discovering your brand through social media, engaging with email campaigns, or making purchase decisions through retargeting ads? Understanding how customers move through your funnel will help you choose a model that best reflects this journey.
Align with Your Marketing Goals
Your choice of attribution model should align with your overarching marketing goals. If you’re focused on brand awareness, first-click attribution may be more appropriate. If your focus is on driving conversions, last-click or time decay models might be a better fit. Multi-touch models like linear or position-based are ideal if your goal is to understand how various channels work together to drive results.
Consider the Length and Complexity of Your Sales Cycle
Short sales cycles may lend themselves well to last-click attribution, where a single touchpoint can drive a purchase decision. However, if your sales cycle is longer and involves multiple touchpoints across different channels, a multi-touch model like linear or position-based will give you a more accurate view of how your marketing activities contribute to conversions over time.
Evaluate Your Resources
If you have limited resources or data, simpler models like first-click or last-click are easier to implement and analyze. For companies with more robust analytics capabilities, custom or algorithmic attribution models provide a more nuanced and accurate picture of performance.
Test and Refine Over Time
Attribution is not a one-size-fits-all solution. You may need to test different models to see which provides the most useful insights for your business. As your marketing strategy evolves, you can refine or switch models to get more accurate performance measurement.

Understand Your Customer Journey
Mapping out your customer journey is the first step in selecting an attribution model. Identify the key touchpoints where customers interact with your brand. Are they discovering your brand through social media, engaging with email campaigns, or making purchase decisions through retargeting ads? Understanding how customers move through your funnel will help you choose a model that best reflects this journey.
Align with Your Marketing Goals
Your choice of attribution model should align with your overarching marketing goals. If you’re focused on brand awareness, first-click attribution may be more appropriate. If your focus is on driving conversions, last-click or time decay models might be a better fit. Multi-touch models like linear or position-based are ideal if your goal is to understand how various channels work together to drive results.
Consider the Length and Complexity of Your Sales Cycle
Short sales cycles may lend themselves well to last-click attribution, where a single touchpoint can drive a purchase decision. However, if your sales cycle is longer and involves multiple touchpoints across different channels, a multi-touch model like linear or position-based will give you a more accurate view of how your marketing activities contribute to conversions over time.
Evaluate Your Resources
If you have limited resources or data, simpler models like first-click or last-click are easier to implement and analyze. For companies with more robust analytics capabilities, custom or algorithmic attribution models provide a more nuanced and accurate picture of performance.
Test and Refine Over Time
Attribution is not a one-size-fits-all solution. You may need to test different models to see which provides the most useful insights for your business. As your marketing strategy evolves, you can refine or switch models to get more accurate performance measurement.

Understand Your Customer Journey
Mapping out your customer journey is the first step in selecting an attribution model. Identify the key touchpoints where customers interact with your brand. Are they discovering your brand through social media, engaging with email campaigns, or making purchase decisions through retargeting ads? Understanding how customers move through your funnel will help you choose a model that best reflects this journey.
Align with Your Marketing Goals
Your choice of attribution model should align with your overarching marketing goals. If you’re focused on brand awareness, first-click attribution may be more appropriate. If your focus is on driving conversions, last-click or time decay models might be a better fit. Multi-touch models like linear or position-based are ideal if your goal is to understand how various channels work together to drive results.
Consider the Length and Complexity of Your Sales Cycle
Short sales cycles may lend themselves well to last-click attribution, where a single touchpoint can drive a purchase decision. However, if your sales cycle is longer and involves multiple touchpoints across different channels, a multi-touch model like linear or position-based will give you a more accurate view of how your marketing activities contribute to conversions over time.
Evaluate Your Resources
If you have limited resources or data, simpler models like first-click or last-click are easier to implement and analyze. For companies with more robust analytics capabilities, custom or algorithmic attribution models provide a more nuanced and accurate picture of performance.
Test and Refine Over Time
Attribution is not a one-size-fits-all solution. You may need to test different models to see which provides the most useful insights for your business. As your marketing strategy evolves, you can refine or switch models to get more accurate performance measurement.

Conclusion

Selecting the right marketing attribution model is essential for understanding which channels and touchpoints drive the most value for your business. By choosing the model that best aligns with your customer journey, marketing goals, and available resources, you can make data-driven decisions, optimize your campaigns, and improve ROI.

Need help determining the best attribution model for your business? Let’s connect to discuss how Bloom Consulting Group can help you implement an attribution strategy that accurately measures your marketing performance.

Ready to grow?

Let’s Talk About Your Marketing Goals.

Get Started

CONTACT

Services